Movie Review- "The Reader"

There are 2 cards which I must lay out on the table before I begin the actual review. One, I am on a personal quest to see all of the nominees for Best Picture. And 2, drama is my favorite genre of film. I mean, I love a good heavy drama. Those types of movies satisfy me like a good nap or a great meal. If this is the case, then "The Reader" certainly hit the spot.

The film is about a teenager who random meets, then begins an affair with a middle-aged woman. They spend time together, they make love, and he reads to her various literary classics which he is studying in school. The affair lasts a summer, but the young man finds that she has left an indelible mark on his life. He encounters her years later when, as a law student, he observes the woman on trial at Nuremberg, accused of being in the SS and participating in the Nazi atrocities. This, of course, make him conflicted. The rest of the film deals with her life in prison, and how they carry on their "affair", but in a different way. He records classic literature on tape and sends it to her.

The film is at times both touching and depressing. I got the sense that in some odd way, they really do love each other, even though they do not extend the physical aspects of their affair past that one summer. After all, doomed love, tragic love, tortured love is a theme which has inspired some of the world's greatest works of art.

The acting was very, very good. Kate Winslet gives a fine performance. All she needs to become the next Meryl Streep is a few more accents and about 20 more Oscar nods. That said, her performance is really strong in this one. It is easy and tempting to simply say that she gives a powerful performance as a former Nazi. But there are other facets of her character as well. Particularly of note is her behavior at the beginning of the affair. She, teaches the youth to be a lover, and then to be a better one. Winslet pulls this off so well, that the reading itself becomes erotic. Additionally, Ralph Fiennes gives a strong, but understated performance. He plays the teenager as an adult (post-law school).

The film is very deep when it comes to the discussion factor. In other words, the film raises many issues for discussion. These include (but are not limited to) age issues in relationships, the nature of love, the place and limits of forgiveness in relationships, how those relationships change over time, the definition of justice and its relation to law, as well as others.

There's really only one (for me anyway) identifiable person to fit the "that guy" factor. In this case it's Bruno Ganz. He played Hitler in "Downfall". But I recognized him as Staupitz from the 2003 film "Luther."

Just as an aside, this is probably my pick for Best Picture right now.

Acting: A
Directing: A-
That Guy: B
Overall: A-